absolutely-walnuts:

themuditaendeavour:

bogleech:

deliciousstomach:

gwinny3k:

The worst trick a childhood anxiety disorder pulls is, you spend your early years being applauded for being so much more mature than your peers, because you aren’t disruptive, you don’t want any kind of attention, you don’t express yourself, you keep yourself to yourself – this makes you a pleasure to have in class, etc etc – and you start to believe it’s virtue. But you’re actually way behind your peers in normal social development, and who knows if you can ever catch up.

Never heard a truer thing in my life.

holy shit wait you mean being just morbidly terrified of doing anything wrong ISN’T necessarily the same as being “well behaved?!”

Convenient children =/= healthy children

Convenient children do not equal healthy children

No, Jesse Singal, the fact that life is complex does not mean that you cannot trust the identity of transgender people

crossdreamers:

image

Some of you may have read Jesse Singal’s article about transgender people in The Atlantic.  Singal presents a narrative where female to male transgender people are confused and misled. Since some gender variant people find peace with their assigned gender, the story implies, others could too.

If you are trans, I am sure some transphobes will show it to you, your friends or your family. The misgendering in The Atlantic’s promo tweet (above) gives them all they need.

“Liberals” who try to undermine the legitimacy of transgender identities can actually do more harm than binary conservatives. Singal  makes use of the fact that there is a spectrum of gender identities to imply that the ones who truly need help transitioning, may not be who they think they are.

Anti-trans “liberals” like Singal will often argue that since life is complex, messy and fluid  (which is true), means that trans kids cannot be trusted when they tell you who they are  (which is not true).  

If a young person continuously and persistently – and over a long period of time – tells you that they are a girl, a boy or some shade of non-binary, you’d better believe them.

Andrea James has written an excellent analysis of the text over at Boing Boing, which gives you the ideological and political context.

I am also taking the liberty of republishing a twitter thread written by Booker Mendes. It gives you the main arguments for why the narrative presented by Singal is so dangerous. 

image
image
image
image
image
image
image

See also trans philosopher and activist Julia Serano’s twitter thread about Jesse Singal’s history of anti-trans activism.

Serano also has an article that gives an overview over the transgender children debate.  Detransition, Desistance, and Disinformation.

Finally, Zack Ford of Think Progress has a good comment here

No, Jesse Singal, the fact that life is complex does not mean that you cannot trust the identity of transgender people